Reports released by the B.C. government last week reveal that of the $7 billion money laundered in BC in 2018, $5.3B (or 72%) was in real estate. Both revealed how criminals are using real estate to clean their money. As a result, the BC Government has called for a public enquiry into the problem.
The premier says, “The depth and the magnitude of money laundering in British Columbia was far worse than we imagined.” Finance Minister Carole James says, "Housing should provide shelter, not a vehicle for proceeds of crime." She continues, “Homes in BC are for people, not speculative investment or money laundering.”
However, is a public enquiry needed? We have extensive material from two recently released reports. Is there anything more we can learn? Let’s do a quick review of what we do know.
The two recently released reports that have sparked the public enquiry are the Combating Money Laundering in B.C. Real Estate report which puts forward 29 recommendations; and the aptly named, Dirty Money Part 2 which outlines some of the red flags that signal when illegal money is behind a real-estate purchase — including unfinanced purchases, private lending, unusual interest rates and purchases by homemakers and students. Both documents identify numerous gaps in provincial and federal regulatory systems for keeping track of purchases and reporting suspicious transactions.
There are many actions to be taken. The BC Government has already taken some action that includes introducing proposed legislation called the "Land Owner Transparency Act.” This Act would establish a public registry of beneficial owners of property in BC. Corporations, trusts and partnerships that buy land would be required to disclose their beneficial owners in the registry hopefully ending the use of these vehicles to shield real estate purchases. Transparency International Canada highlighted Vancouver real estate in a 2016 report, concluding nearly one-third of the 100 most valuable residential properties in Greater Vancouver were owned by shell companies.
There is also the 30 Point Housing Plan – BC Document. The main features of the plan are a speculation tax, a ramped-up foreign buyers’ tax, and a new property transfer tax:
The speculation tax is aimed at both the current 25,000 and future residences owned by local profiteers, out-of-province investors and “satellite families” who buy up housing stock and leave the homes empty, or vest nominal ownership in a “homemaker” or “student” who pays little if any taxes. If it is found that the declared taxable household incomes are lower than the amount they pay in property taxes, utilities and mortgage payments; and equivalent incomes to those reported in the Downtown Eastside. CRA estimates that about $170 million in taxes went uncollected from BC real estate over the past three years. The speculation tax aims to fix this disconnect between declared income and housing wealth.
The existing (and largely ineffectual) 15 per cent Metro Vancouver foreign buyers’ tax will increase to 20 per cent; and
The new 5 per cent property transfer tax will target sales of homes worth $3 million and up.
These are the efforts underway to undo a decade of political indifference that turned Vancouver into an epicentre of fraud, scams and real estate mania. Will this be enough? The current picture of the Vancouver housing market is not pretty. Here is more data.
A Globe investigation;"> published in February, 2018, uncovered how 17 underground lenders provided $47 million in drug-money mortgages and liens on 45 Metro Vancouver mansions. An RCMP intelligence report estimated that up to $1-billion from the proceeds of crime was used to purchase expensive Metro Vancouver homes.
Vancouver has become known as a free trade zone for gangland money launderers, absentee offshore real-estate speculators, Chinese princelings on the lam and globe-trotting tax frauds. Over the past decade, homelessness has doubled, at least 4,000 people are sleeping rough in the streets, and there are now 70 homeless camps across the region.
In January 2018, Vancouver showed up as the third most unaffordable city on Demographia’s list of 92 cities around the world. When it comes to cities undergoing a deterioration in housing affordability, Vancouver ends up the worst.
At least we have a starting point and a current BC Government that has expressed their commitment to address the issues. The Public Enquiry will release an interim report within 18 months and a final report by May 2021. The BC election is scheduled for October 2021.
We at CCEC plan to keep our members informed on developments in this area.